Innovative approaches like cloud seeding have created interest as possible solutions to ease water availability and help adapt to climate issues, as climate change continues to disrupt weather patterns across the globe. However, the question is – can cloud seeding be a sustainable response to the challenges of climate change?
What is Cloud Seeding?
Cloud seeding is a weather modification technique in which materials like silver iodide or salt are dispersed into clouds to enhance precipitation, inducing rain or snow. Cloud seeding technology has been in use around the world for decades to assist with water availability to support agriculture and help alleviate drought stress.
Potential Benefits for the Climate
Cloud seeding can offer a variety of benefits that align with climate adaptation goals. Increasing rainfall or snowpack replenishes groundwater and reservoirs, which is incredibly important to communities experiencing climate-related water scarcity. In addition to replenishing sources of water, which reduces drought frequency or disruptions, with benefits attached to the precipitation induced with cloud seeding, the agriculture sector would see productivity increased, and improve ecosystems as well.
Cloud seeding can improve air quality by inducing artificial rain that
helps wash out particulates, effectively reducing urban congestion and
pollution levels. While air quality improvements may not directly relate to climate resilience, they do lend support for the overall health of individuals, while also limiting the impacts of the urban heat island effect.
Environmental and Sustainability Issues
While cloud seeding shows promise, it is not without issues. Cloud seeding could work under certain conditions. Its success depends on the presence of the right cloud type, with sufficient moisture. When experiencing extreme drought and because clouds are scarce, or clouds are dry, cloud seeding will not necessarily create rain.
There are questions about the impact of repeatedly using silver iodide, as it is the main ingredient for seeding the cloud. It is considered low-risk at typical concentrations of silver iodide, but we must continue to monitor the soil and water for potential long-term environmental impact. Sustainable cloud seeding involves the use of regulated chemicals, and also involves environmental impact assessments and limited area of use.
Ethical and Operational Issues
Ethically, cloud seeding may potentially change where rainfall occurs and result in unwanted effects somewhere else, such as taking away rainfall from downwind areas. International cooperation and careful regional planning is important to understand and develop monitoring strategies.
Operationally, cloud seeding is expensive, requires specialized equipment (aircraft or drone) and using weather data at an exact time and area for the potential of success. Cloud seeding is not a single solution to climate change but can be made part of a comprehensive water management and climate adaption plan.
Scientific Controversy and research tracking
There is controversy over the opinion of scientists regarding the efficiency of cloud seeding. There are some studies that say, under the right conditions, there could be a 10-25% increase in rainfall, while some of these same studies point out that the increase witnessed in the temperature logs does not exist.
Cases like Delhi’s recent cloud seeding efforts show both promise and limitations and show that it is critical to manage expectations and ensure transparency.
Conclusion
Cloud seeding has potential as a complementary resource to help with climate change-driven water shortages and air pollution. When applied responsibly, with adequate environmental protections and scientific principles, it could enhance precipitation to support ecosystems and agriculture.
Cloud seeding is not a ‘one size fits all‘ solution. Meteorological conditions determine the sustainability of cloud seeding, and responsible use of chemicals, ethical governance, regulation, and integration into climate adaptability frameworks support it. Ongoing innovation, international collaboration, and comprehensive research ensure its responsible and sustainable use.
Leave a Comment